My question has been posted on stackexchange here: http://ift.tt/1iRMGZl
But I wanted to ask you all since it's really a better fit for physicsforums' format. The question is copied below.
=============
This is a question about Chapter 10.9 of Elementary Classical Analysis by Marsden and Hoffman.
The following passages are quoted from page 612 of the second edition.
Then, on pg. 614, it says
So we have the partial derivative with respect to time of a function defined on a space of *positions*. What is going on here? How can one take the derivative with respect to time of a function defined on 3-space? It seems to me to be at worst, totally illogical, and at best, extremely careless.
The reason I ask these questions (besides just wanting to understand) is because I have to do the following problem, which makes use of the second concept.
As the above is a homework problem, I don't want any help on it. But if the problem is inherently contradictory, please let me know. Thanks in advance.
But I wanted to ask you all since it's really a better fit for physicsforums' format. The question is copied below.
=============
This is a question about Chapter 10.9 of Elementary Classical Analysis by Marsden and Hoffman.
The following passages are quoted from page 612 of the second edition.
Quote:
[Suppose] [itex]\mathcal{V} = L^2[/itex] is the space of functions [itex]\psi: \mathbb{R}^3 \to \mathbb{C}[/itex] that are square integrable: [tex] \| \psi \|^2 = \langle \psi, \psi \rangle = \int \psi(x) \overline{\psi(x)} dx < \infty. [/tex] A quantum mechanical state is (by definition) a function [itex]\psi \in \mathcal{V}[/itex] such that [itex]\| \psi \| = 1[/itex]; that is, [itex]\psi[/itex] is normalized. |
Then, on pg. 614, it says
Quote:
[This] operator governs the time dependence of [itex]\psi[/itex] by means of the celebrated Schrödinger equation, which reads [tex] i\hbar \frac{\partial \psi}{\partial t} = H\psi. [/tex] |
So we have the partial derivative with respect to time of a function defined on a space of *positions*. What is going on here? How can one take the derivative with respect to time of a function defined on 3-space? It seems to me to be at worst, totally illogical, and at best, extremely careless.
The reason I ask these questions (besides just wanting to understand) is because I have to do the following problem, which makes use of the second concept.
Quote:
Suppose [itex]i\hbar(\partial \psi/\partial t) = H\psi[/itex]. Prove that [itex]\langle \psi, H\psi\rangle[/itex] is constant in time. This result is called conservation of energy. |
As the above is a homework problem, I don't want any help on it. But if the problem is inherently contradictory, please let me know. Thanks in advance.
0 commentaires:
Enregistrer un commentaire